We can learn a lot from looking at portraits of dead people, or ‘posthumous portraits’ to sound less ghoulish. If you read between the brushstrokes and know what to look for, a posthumous portrait can reveal cultural attitudes to death in a particular time and place.
Going, going… gone
Portraits of the deceased can seem shocking today, particularly those of children. Why would you want to remember the gloomy event of a death? It is hard to imagine viewing these severe and painful images as an act of reverence, but many early examples were made when having a portrait created wasn't a common occurrence, and people were in more frequent contact with the dead and dying. If someone got sick and the prognosis wasn't good, it was time to gather together and perhaps call for the local portraitist to come to the afflicted person’s bedside to immortalise their face in paint – while they were still around.
... in order to position the body in a semblance of liveliness, the photographer may need to open the eyes of the deceased. But ‘this you can effect handily by using the handle of a teaspoon’...
The subject above still has some colour in his face, in contrast to the white linens – though the black bow and pained expression is a reminder that William
This view of The Last Moments of HRH the Prince Consort was a little too close to the death bed: Queen Victoria was horrified by its existence and wanted to have the picture destroyed (but it survived and was bought by the collector Henry S. Wellcome).
Most posthumous portraits show the person as they looked when alive. For those of higher social standing, there were usually other portraits a posthumous work could be based on (unless you were the abbé de Saint-Cyran, who refused to have his portrait taken during his life – the original artist worked from a death mask). An image made after death can emphasise a person’s worthy
It is sometimes hard to spot a posthumous work unless symbolism has been used – for example, stopped clocks or hourglasses (as in Memorial Portrait of Sir John Harpur, above), wilted roses, departing ships, obelisks, using the colours red, white and black together, or a weeping willow. My research into the death date of Francis Page of Newbury (below) came up with little, though I wonder if the drooping willow branches in this portrait signify the work is posthumous? (Art Detectives: let us know if you have a clue.) With only basic information, viewing portraits such as these can prove speculative.
Though discovering a portrait is posthumous can bring about a fresh appreciation of the work. In 2014, Art Detectives identified an unknown soldier as Second Lieutenant Paul Chancourt Giradot, killed in 1916. After the discovery was publicised, more information came to light: the artist was likely the deceased’s mother, Mary Jane Girardot. Mary also immortalised his portrait in a church’s stained glass window. (I’ll be following another Art Detective discussion relating to a portrait of James Clapperton, who ran away aged 16 and was lost at sea. It seems too finely painted not to have been made from life, but its sensitive rendering might imply the work is posthumous...)
With posthumous portraits made to
Dearly departed: children and families
After the sudden death of nine-year-old Barbara Anne, her parents went on the Grand Tour as a distraction from their grief. Whilst in Rome in around 1750, they met the painter Pompeo Batoni. Batoni painted the glowing, angelic likeness of Barbara Anne from a miniature the couple had brought along on their travels. The expression of longing the artist captured on the mother’s face is almost painful to view.
Some posthumous portrait commissions can cross into otherworldly territory, combining both
With other well-documented art, we know enough to recognise when a scene, presented as reality, has been made with
In a later story, John Singleton Copley worked doggedly for years on a group portrait of the Knatchbull family. The painter included Knatchbull’s deceased first wife as an angel, but when nearing the end of the painting, his second wife also died. Copley made room for the second wife as another angel (before a third wife became pregnant: Knatchbull then insisted space be made in the composition for the newborn).
As we can understand from Copley’s difficult commission, it's not easy painting the dead. For history’s portraitists, particularly struggling artists, working directly with a corpse was not unusual – in fact, the ghoulish task would usually be left to poor young upstarts. Advice to makers of Victorian posthumous daguerreotypes (a close cousin of the posthumous portrait painter) reveals that in order to position the body in a semblance of liveliness, the photographer may need to open the eyes of the deceased. But ‘this you can effect handily by using the handle of a teaspoon’, advised Charlie E. Orr. Other artists used
Girl in Blue, by William Matthew Prior, could be the result of some such commission: Prior’s solemn children on Art UK are all the more haunting when one learns the artist may have lost a wife and six children by 1848.
Contemporary posthumous portraits
Now, most people rely on photographs to remember the deceased. Yet occasionally painters are asked to commemorate a deceased person, and in doing so face their own challenges. The artist may have many source photographs to work from, but this also means the commissioner may expect a photorealist
These commissions are a stark contrast to posthumous artworks made for personal reasons. Contemporary works are often by bereaved relatives of the subject, wanting to produce a lasting emblem of the character now departed: Robert Lutyens painted his father, Edward from a photograph because the artist felt every other portrait made his father look 'over-serious'. Artists may also paint posthumous portraits as a form of therapy. The ritual of painting from life can be meditative and help an artist contemplate or work through difficult feelings.
Looking at many posthumous portraits for this article, I found Robert Oskar Lenkiewicz’s Study of the Painter's Dead Mother the most difficult to view. The dead pallor of the subject’s skin is shocking – this hints that death is culturally alien to contemporary viewers. Perhaps in looking at something you become less frightened: a good reason to look closely at these complex portraits.
Jade King, Art UK Head of Editorial